CCTA View Up in the Air: When is it appropriate to lend to those with CCJs?

This is an archived post from 24 October 2022.

read article back to Latest News

In the latest issue of CCTA Magazine, we asked Lex Jones of the Registry Trust to talk a little more about the importance of the work that they do on county court judgments (CCJs).

The CCTA is a strong supporter of their Get Satisfaction campaign. It is vital to ensure judgments are kept up to date. When CCJs are satisfied it is important that there is a record. This should be a win-win for both the customer and lenders.

Consumer Duty focuses on good outcomes.

The Consumer Duty makes clear that a lender should deliver the best outcome for a customer. That includes making sure information is passed along about a CCJ.

Looking into the future, surely this is a useful indication. Especially if the customer has corrected their position. Especially if they have taken steps to put things right. Surely this is an indication that they may be a suitable customer in the future.

From a behavioural perspective, in terms of credit risk, a lender might view favourably someone who has not just let time run down on their CCJ.

Should CCJs prevent future lending?

However, this is only relevant if the regulator doesn’t close lending to those with CCJs.

This was one of the issues that emerged from industry discussions held with CCTA members earlier in the year. It became a concern that the FCA seemed to be questioning whether it was right to lend to people who had CCJs.

This was an issue that emerged from an informal conversation among members. We said at the time that we would pursue this further with the FCA. For us, the concern was that this looked like a misunderstanding of the nature of the market that many high-cost lenders serve.

We believe that, especially in subprime, customers may well have had a CCJ.

FCA provides clarification.

In a statement that we were told we could share with the membership, we were assured that the FCA’s position is not that you cannot lend to a customer with a CCJ.

They said to us, “A firm should have regard to any information of which it is aware of at the time the creditworthiness assessment is carried out that may indicate that the customer is in, has recently experienced, or is likely to experience, financial difficulties. The fact that a customer has a CCJ is likely to be relevant to this assessment.”

Hopefully, that provides some assurance that there is no outright ban.

They went on, “The extent and scope of the creditworthiness assessment, and the steps that the firm must take to satisfy the requirement that the assessment is a reasonable one, based on sufficient information, are dependent upon, and proportionate to, the individual circumstances of each case. The presence of a CCJ may be a factor suggesting that a more rigorous affordability assessment is necessary.”

The quicker amongst you may realise that this is also not an endorsement of this lending. There is enough in that explanation, with a mention of proportionality, that supervisors could use to close this down while not imposing a full stop.

Are CCJs really an indicator of affordability?

There is also a deeper question as to whether CCJs are actually an indicator of a problem around affordability. What does a CCJ say about whether someone can afford to pay back a loan? Especially if the CCJ is reasonably old. Affordability is not about whether the borrower will pay back, it is about whether they can pay back.

A discussion for another day, maybe.

For now, lenders should consider the advice from the FCA that a CCJ is a flag but not a reason for decline. Lenders need to show that they take this matter as a reason to step up their affordability assessment. It also reinforces the need for CCJ information to be kept up to date by lenders.

become a ccta member back to Latest News
JOIN CCTA

CCTA Membership

Instalment Options on Request

sole traders & startups

From £66 per month

Paid annually at £800 +VAT

lenders & brokers

From £117 per month

Paid annually at £1,400 +VAT

associate firms

From £159 per month

Paid annually at £1,908 +VAT

CCTA Membership Packages

Discounts Available

CCTA membership

CCTA academy

CCTA agreements

Request a Quote & Info

Membership Enquiry

SUBMIT TO RECEIVE A QUOTE

    Thank You

    We will be in touch

    Close