Shared Duty, shared outcomes Lenders and brokers: Effective broker oversight

To customers, lenders and brokers are one experience. The FCA’s Consumer Duty makes that explicit: any firm that can determine or materially influence a retail outcome has responsibilities commensurate with its role.

That has real consequences for distribution. Manufacturers must design products for a defined target market and monitor how brokers sell them, including the cumulative impact of fees and commissions on fair value. Discretionary commission models in motor finance are gone, but the principle remains: if incentives can predictably distort outcomes, they must change.

read article back to Latest News

Richard Brown

Director of Advisory Services

Redporth

Due diligence and contracts now need a Duty lens. Lenders should secure the right to MI, audits and mystery shops, and act when visibility is limited. Brokers, for their part, are manufacturers of the broking service: they must evidence fair value in their own charges, disclose commissions in a way customers actually understand, and share information upstream.

If you use Appointed Representatives, remember the FCA has strengthened principal responsibilities: onboarding and scope control, annual reviews, and real-time oversight. Treat AR governance as part of distribution risk, not a separate compliance ritual.

Good practice

  • Map each product’s target market and distribution, then monitor high-risk segments and channels. Build a contractual MI pack (acceptance rates, APR ranges, fees, complaints, arrears, forbearance usage) by broker and act on what it shows.
  • Govern commissions and incentives. You should pre-approve models, test cumulative value (including broker add-ons), and link pay to sustained affordability and customer understanding, not just originations.
  • Assure delivery, not just design. Run file reviews and mystery shopping focused on explanations and vulnerability handling; sample affordability assessments for data sufficiency; set outcome triggers (complaints, early arrears, “worse-off” cohorts) that force interim review and remediation. Report it to the board, not just the compliance committee.

Why this matters

The regulator’s scrutiny of motor-finance complaints and the in-flight redress scheme shows the direction of travel: you will be judged by your outcomes and how quickly you fix them. The smartest firms are acting like one chain, co-designing communications, sharing MI, and aligning incentives to customer success.

If you’re re-cutting broker oversight, fair-value workbooks or AR governance, it is vital that you implement controls that stand up to board and FCA challenge. For example, broker MI heat-maps (acceptance, APR dispersion, early-arrears), pre-approved commission models with outcome back-testing, and a fair-value workbook that captures total economic cost including part-exchange effects. Take the opportunity to build something robust for today and resilient for what comes next.

If you’re refreshing broker oversight, fair-value workbooks, affordability controls or AR governance, take care to build practical controls that stand up to board, and FCA challenge, such as open-banking challenge playbooks with documented sustainability tests, automatic outcome triggers that force interim reviews, and risk-based AR oversight with MI rights, mystery shops and annual onsite reviews, backed by an audit-ready evidence library you can trust.

About Redporth

Redporth is a financial services consultancy, but with some unique differences.

We have built our business around the simple purpose of providing our clients with safety in financial services. In order to deliver on this promise, we have built up a senior team with an unusually broad level of experience across advisory work and resourcing. This experience brings together experience in FCA supervision, legal services, financial services industry and in large-scale financial services consultancies.

This experience results in a range of domestic and international clients from private wealth managers, lenders, brokers, payment services businesses, law firms and other professional services business. We work across most sectors in the financial services industry, with an emphasis on retail finance, motor finance, private wealth, pensions and retail banking. Redporth was set up with the simple promise of offering our clients a no-nonsense approach. We are passionate about providing value for money and have built this into everything that we do.

For more information, visit www.redporth.com.

JOIN CCTA

CCTA Membership

Instalment Options on Request

sole traders & startups

From £80 per month

Paid annually at £950 +VAT

lenders & brokers

From £162 per month

Paid annually at £1,945 +VAT

associate firms

From £180 per month

Paid annually at £2,150 +VAT

CCTA Membership Packages

Discounts Available

CCTA membership

CCTA academy

CCTA agreements

Request a Quote & Info

Membership Enquiry

SUBMIT TO RECEIVE A QUOTE

    Thank You

    We will be in touch

    Close